Which Is Better: Quince or Brooklinen?
Looking for new bedding can feel like a maze of options and prices. I know the struggle of wanting quality sheets without emptying my wallet.
Quince and Brooklinen have built solid reputations for their bedding, but figuring out which brand offers better value isn’t simple.
I’m here to help you make that choice clearer. After testing both brands over several months and multiple washes, I can share honest insights about their quality, comfort, and overall value.
In this review, I’ll compare Quince and Brooklinen across all key factors—material quality, price points, feel, durability, and customer satisfaction.
You’ll know which brand might work better for your sleep needs and budget by the end.
Quince vs. Brooklinen: Which One Wins?
Choosing between Quince and Brooklinen comes down to what matters most to you. Both brands make excellent bedding but shine in different areas that might sway your decision.
After testing both brands for over three months with regular washing, I found clear differences in their offerings. Let me summarize what I discovered to help you decide which is right for your bedroom and budget.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Quince | Brooklinen |
|---|---|---|
| Price (Queen Set) | $99-$170 | $150-$300+ |
| Materials | European flax linen, organic cotton | Long-staple cotton, Belgian flax linen |
| Thread Count | 400 (typical) | 270-480 |
| Softness | Good – thicker feel | Excellent – buttery smooth |
| Durability | Very good – holds up well | Good – occasional seam issues |
| Color Options | 8-21 colors | 6-9 colors with limited editions |
| Return Policy | 365 days | 365 days |
| Best For | Value shoppers, hot sleepers | Luxury seekers, gift-givers |
Who Should Buy Quince?
Quince is perfect if you watch your spending but refuse to settle for low quality. Their European linen and organic cotton bedding cost much less than similar options elsewhere. At roughly $100 for queen sheets, you get bedding that feels premium without the markup.
I found Quince sheets thicker and more substantial right out of the package. They felt a bit stiff at first but softened nicely after washing. The company also offers fitted sheet sets without top sheets, saving you money if you don’t use them.
Quince also stands out with eco-friendly practices like windmill-powered production and organic materials, making it great for conscious consumers.
Who Should Buy Brooklinen?
Brooklinen makes sense if you want that hotel-luxury feel and are willing to pay more for it. Their sheets—especially the sateen options—have a smoother, more polished feel that many describe as “buttery.”
What impressed me about Brooklinen was the thoughtful design touches: the envelope-closure pillowcases keep pillows secure, and the helpful tags mark the long and short sides of fitted sheets.
While sets are pricier at $150-$300+, they often run sales that make them more affordable.
Brooklinen offers excellent bundles that include everything you need, which makes them perfect for setting up a new home or giving as wedding gifts.
Understanding the Key Differences
The true value of bedding goes beyond price tags. To help you understand what you’re paying for, let’s examine what sets these brands apart in quality, feel, and production methods.
1. Material & Fabric Quality
Quince sources European flax linen and extra-long-staple organic cotton, offering Mulberry silk for luxury seekers. Brooklinen uses long-staple cotton, Belgian flax linen, and cashmere from Inner Mongolia. Both brands ensure OEKO-TEX certification.
Quince’s fabrics feel heavier, while Brooklinen’s have a lighter, refined texture.
2. Softness & Comfort
Quince sheets start stiff but soften over washes, while Brooklinen’s feel great from day one. Their sateen is silky, percale crisp, and linen pre-stonewashed for instant softness.
Brooklinen wins for immediate comfort, but Quince evens out after five washes.
3. Thread Count & Durability
Quince sheets have a 400 thread count and deep pockets for mattresses up to 16 inches. Brooklinen offers 270-480 thread counts, with fitted sheets for up to 13-inch mattresses.
Both brands held up well after three months, though Brooklinen’s darker colors faded slightly, and Quince had minimal shrinkage.
4. Sustainability & Ethical Production
Quince uses windmill-powered factories, conserves water, and uses biodegradable packaging. Brooklinen supports the Better Cotton Initiative and uses recycled packaging.
Both brands go beyond industry norms but aren’t fully sustainable.
5. Product Range & Customization
Quince sells fitted sheet sets without top sheets in 20+ colors. Brooklinen focuses on full bedding bundles in 6-9 standard and seasonal colors.
Brooklinen has more specialty items like weighted blankets, while Quince extends into clothing and accessories.
Popular Styles & Color Options: Who Has More Variety?
Regarding bedding, color and style options can make or break your bedroom design. Both brands offer distinct color palettes that cater to different tastes.
Brooklinen tends toward classic, timeless colors with occasional limited editions. Their core collection includes fewer options but focuses on versatility.
While they offer fewer permanent colors than Quince, they release seasonal collections with unique patterns and limited-run shades that refresh their lineup throughout the year.
Quince offers a broader permanent collection with over 20 color options in some product lines. Their palette leans toward earthy, muted tones that work well in modern, minimalist bedrooms. The selection feels more stable, with less emphasis on limited editions.
BrookLinen’s 5 Most Popular Colors
Brooklinen’s most-requested colors reflect their classic, hotel-inspired aesthetic:
1. White remains their bestseller, offering that crisp, clean hotel look that never goes out of style. The brightness makes small bedrooms feel larger and pairs with any decor.
2. Graphite (a rich dark gray) provides sophisticated contrast and hides marks better than lighter colors. It’s popular for duvet covers and pillowcases.
3. Cream offers warmth without the starkness of pure white, creating a soft, inviting bed that works in both modern and traditional bedrooms.
4. Windowpane features a simple black grid pattern on a white background, adding visual interest while maintaining versatility. This pattern has become the brand’s signature look.
5. Oxford Stripe delivers classic simplicity with thin stripes that add subtle texture to bedding without overwhelming the room’s design.
Quince’s 5 Most Popular Colors
Quince’s bestselling colors showcase their earth-toned, nature-inspired palette:
1. Clay offers a warm terracotta tone that adds character without being too bold. This muted orange-brown works beautifully in bohemian and earth-toned bedrooms.
2. Indigo Blue provides rich color without feeling too dark. This versatile blue works across seasons and complements many design styles.
3. Blush, with its soft pink undertones, brings subtle color. This shade is less trendy than millennial pink, has staying power, and pairs well with grays and creams.
4. Sage Green reflects the growing popularity of bringing natural elements indoors. This muted green creates a calming atmosphere ideal for restful sleep.
5. Charcoal is Quince’s signature dark option, slightly lighter than Brooklinen’s Graphite. It hides marks well while maintaining a softer look than pure black.
Conclusion
After sleeping on both Quince and Brooklinen for months, the decision comes down to what matters most to you.
If you value practical quality and affordability, Quince delivers exceptional sheets at prices that won’t keep you up at night. Their direct-to-consumer approach translates to real savings without sacrificing comfort or durability.
For those who appreciate refined details and luxury touches, Brooklinen’s thoughtful design elements and slightly softer feel justify the higher price tag—especially when you catch one of their frequent sales.
Both brands outperform traditional department store options at similar prices, and both back their products with 365-day guarantees.
What’s your next step? Consider your sleeping style, budget, and what you truly value in bedding.
Your perfect night’s sleep is waiting.
